Allegany Co-op Insurance Company
9 North Branch Rd
Cuba, NY 14727
(585) 968-1000
(800) 333-1679
After Hours 24 Hour Emergency Claim Service: (800) 887-9474

Executive

Randall Peters, CPA President rpeters@alleganycoop.com

Marian Schneider Executive Assistant mschneider@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6050

Accounting

Holly Stives Controller hstives@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6052

Kim Gilbert Accounting kgilbert@alleganycoop.com

Information Technology

Wendy Minges Information Tech. Specialist wminges@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6053

Claims

Sarah Zulauf, CPCU Vice President, Claims szulauf@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6063	Carolyn Solo Claim Representative csolo@alleganycoop.com Direct Number: (585) 968-6064
Carolyn Gordon Senior Claim Assistant cgordon@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6051

Underwriting

Pam Harrington, AFIS Commercial Lines Underwriter pharrington@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6061	Bobbi-Jo Johnson Personal Lines Underwriter bjohnson@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6058
Jamie Murphy,INS, API Personal Lines Supervising Underwriter jmurphy@alleganycoop.com Direct Number: (585) 968-6055	Rose Jones Commercial Lines Underwriter rjones@alleganycoop.com
Adam Holota Loss Control Specialist aholota@alleganycoop.com	Summer Carney Commercial Lines Accounts Receivable Clerk scarney@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6060
Nathan Jacoby Commercial Lines Underwriter njacoby@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6062	Tonya Metatos Personal Lines Underwriter tmetatos@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6057
Debbi Hopkins Underwriting Clerk dhopkins@alleganycoop.com	Wendy Clark Underwriting Assistant wclark@alleganycoop.com
Marvin Achilles, CPCU Senior VP, Underwriting machilles@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6054	Joyce Amundson Personal Lines Accounts Receivable Clerk jamundson@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6056
Marketing Representative Dave Nagle Marketing Representative dnagle@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6059

Receptionist

Lori Stephens Receptionist lstephens@alleganycoop.com

Allegany North Office (Rochester Location)

Dennis H. Kindred Branch Manager/Special Investigations dkindred@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6069	Andrea Catone Assistant Branch Manager acatone@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6065
Melanie Stam Underwriting Supervisor mstam@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6067	Karen L. Taber Underwriter ktaber@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6066
Jo Ann Caraballo Claims Representative jcaraballo@alleganycoop.com Direct Number:  (585) 968-6068